The turtles are endanger species which numerous of them trapped in the shrimp boat. One solution for the issue is turtle excluder device.

The turtles are endanger species which numerous of them trapped in the shrimp boat. One solution for the issue is turtle excluder device. The article states that TED will failed to protect turtles practically using an array of reasons. On the contrary, the professor cites various examples and motives to reject the points in the reading. First, the writer explains the turtles that trapped by the shrimp boats are insignificant. In fact, the shrimp boats catch only one turtle per month regularly. In addition, a huge amount of the shrimps could release themselves from the net because of the TED, which make it insufficient. Conversely, the professor argues there are tremendous amount of boats and if every boat just kill a turtle there will be a lot of dead turtle. The effect should be access as a whole, not separately. Second, the writer suggests the substitute method for saving the turtles. The government could legislate new regulation to require the boats to keep their nets under the water only for a specific time, which turtles are able to stay alive without air. In contrast, the professor asserts the proposed solution is not practical, due to the fact, the state authorities could not supervise how the boat obey the rule. However, TED could be easily observe by the governors. Finally, the writer claims the TED are not effective for larger animals. In some parts there are bigger animals; for example, leatherback turtles that could not pass from the TED. On the contrary, the speaker declares the TED could be modify for various size of animals. In conclusion the the professor casts doubt on the criticism made by the author.