The argument claims that the plan of building a large mall in the newly constructed outside city area will attract
wealthy clients of Littleville. In support of the claim, the author also stated that such a plan that was executed ten
years ago, in the same province, was successful in attracting the clients and was successful in no time. To evaluate this
recommendation, we need to know the answers of three questions.
First of all, is the scenario of ten years old Bigsburg and today's Littleville the same? Or in other words, is it still
valid that people still want to go to big shopping malls to buy luxury things the same way they did ten years ago? The
situations might be completely different now. People might want to save time nowadays and prefer online shopping more
than going to shopping malls. If these assumptions are any true, these would undermine the author's recommendation.
Secondly, are the residents of Littleville eager to the newly constructed zone outside the city to shop wealthy stuff?
This is a big question that needs to be evaluated before executing such big plans. Perhaps the people in Littleville feel
more easy to stay inside the city area for shopping. Perhaps Littleville is a very big city compounding a large area that
takes a good amount of time to travel all the way outside the city to reach the newly constructed area. Perhaps the
transportation system in Littleville is still not that advanced and its hard for people to find a transport to go
outside the city. There should be a survey executed with the residents of Littleville taking this problems in account. If any of these is true, Littleville's new project of constructing the mall might be in question.
Finally, perhaps the most important one, haven't been any high class and well categorized mall built in Littleville's
downtown area in these past ten years? Is there no other alternative malls that the residents can choose within the city
boundary? It can be easier for them to shop from any high class malls within the city boundary. If there are other big malls,
why would the people of Littleville go outside their city?
In conclusion of the argument, as it stands now, is flawed. More evidences should be provided to evaluate this flawed
argument. The questions should be answered and more surveys should be conducted to find out the answers.
The argument claims that the plan of building a large
mall
in the
newly
constructed
outside
city
area
will attract
wealthy
clients of
Littleville
. In support of the claim, the author
also
stated that such a plan that
was executed
ten
years
ago, in the same province, was successful in attracting the clients and was successful in no time. To evaluate
this
recommendation
, we need to know the answers of three questions.
First of all
, is the scenario of ten years
old
Bigsburg
and
today
's
Littleville
the same? Or
in other words
, is it
still
valid
that
people
still
want to go to
big
shopping
malls
to
buy
luxury things the same way they did ten years ago? The
situations
might be completely
different
now
.
People
might want to save time nowadays and prefer online
shopping
more
than
going to
shopping
malls
. If these assumptions are any true, these would undermine the author's recommendation.
Secondly
, are the residents of
Littleville
eager to the
newly
constructed zone
outside
the city to shop wealthy stuff?
This is a
big
question that needs to
be evaluated
before
executing such
big
plans. Perhaps the
people
in
Littleville
feel
more
easy to stay inside the city
area
for
shopping
. Perhaps
Littleville
is a
very
big
city compounding a large
area
that
takes
a
good
amount of time to travel all the way
outside
the city to reach the
newly
constructed
area
. Perhaps
the
transportation system in
Littleville
is
still
not that advanced and its
hard
for
people
to find
a transport
to go
outside
the city. There should be a survey executed with the residents of
Littleville
taking
this
problems in account. If any of these is true,
Littleville
's new project of constructing the
mall
might be in question.
Finally
, perhaps the most
important
one, haven't been any high
class
and well categorized
mall
built in
Littleville
's
downtown
area
in these past ten years? Is there no other alternative
malls
that the residents can choose within the
city
boundary
? It can be easier for them to shop from any high
class
malls
within the city boundary. If there are other
big
malls,
why would the
people
of
Littleville
go
outside
their city?
In conclusion
of the argument, as it stands
now
,
is flawed
. More evidences should
be provided
to evaluate this
flawed
argument
. The questions should
be answered
and more surveys should
be conducted
to find out the answers.