There is a writing about a painting which is said that it is not a painting of Rembrandt, and there is a lecture about it which is said that it is Rembrandt's painting. Summarize the points made in the lecture, being sure explain how they answer the
There is a writing about a painting which is said that it is not a painting of Rembrandt, and there is a lecture about it which is said that it is Rembrandt's painting. Summarize the points made in the lecture, being sure explain how they answer the NrnRj
In this set of materials, the reading passage and the listening section are about a painting called Portrait of an Elderly Woman in a White Bonnet. While the writer is in the opinion that it was not painted by Rembrandt's himself, the lecturer claims that it is an original painting made by Rembrandt.
Firstly, the writer states that there is a contradict between the cloths of woman in the painting, so as a careful painter Rembrant did not lose attention for details. On the other hand, the lecturer points out that the pigments in the painting are shown as in the original paintings, thus it was probably painted by Rembrandt.
Secondly, the writer indicates that although in the painting the face of woman is illuminated by light reflected onto it from below, the face is in dark. As a master of painting, Rembrandt did not make such an error. In contrast, the lecturer says that the painter used simple color to be reflected by light. Thus, the face of woman was illuminated. This is so realistic as in the original paintings of Remberandt.
Lastly, according to author although Rembrandt often painted on single wood panels, this painting was painted on a panel made of several pieces of wood, so it is probably not Remberandt's painting. On the contrary, the professor states that it is true that Rembrandt's orginal paintings was made on single piece of wood, but Portrait of an Elderly Woman in a White Bonnet was made on a piece of wood enlarged.
All in all, while the writer states that several proufs shows that Portrait of an Eldery Woman in a White Bonnet is not a painting of Rembrandt, the lecturer opposes this idea with three claims.
In this set of materials, the reading passage and the listening section are about a
painting
called Portrait of an Elderly
Woman
in a White Bonnet. While the
writer
is in the opinion that it was not
painted
by Rembrandt's himself, the
lecturer
claims that it is an original
painting
made by Rembrandt.
Firstly
, the
writer
states that there is
a contradict
between the cloths of
woman
in the
painting
,
so
as a careful painter
Rembrant
did not lose attention for
details
.
On the other hand
, the
lecturer
points out that the pigments in the
painting
are shown
as in the original
paintings
,
thus
it was
probably
painted
by Rembrandt.
Secondly
, the
writer
indicates that although in the
painting
the face of
woman
is illuminated
by light reflected onto it from below, the face is in dark. As a master of
painting
, Rembrandt did not
make
such an error.
In contrast
, the
lecturer
says that the painter
used
simple color to
be reflected
by light.
Thus
, the face of
woman
was illuminated
. This is
so
realistic as in the original
paintings
of
Remberandt
.
Lastly
, according to author although Rembrandt
often
painted
on single
wood
panels, this
painting
was
painted
on a panel made of several pieces of
wood
,
so
it is
probably
not
Remberandt
's
painting
.
On the contrary
, the professor states that it is true that Rembrandt's
orginal
paintings
was made
on single piece of
wood
,
but
Portrait of an Elderly
Woman
in a White Bonnet
was made
on a piece of
wood
enlarged.
All in all, while the
writer
states that several
proufs
shows
that Portrait of an
Eldery
Woman
in a White Bonnet is not a
painting
of Rembrandt, the
lecturer
opposes this
idea
with three claims.