The question of which skills to prioritize for a child’s early education is important for all
parents and educators, and music can certainly claim to be a key possibility when deciding which abilities to teach. However, I feel that playing music is actually less important than basic literacy, and I will explain the reasons here.
Firstly, it seems simplistic to say that music is paramount ‘for all children. ’ Certainly, there are some children who are highly talented or have great interest in music, and when we think of childhood prodigies such as Beethoven or Yehudi Menuhin we see how this talent can be brought out. However, such talents are rare, and even the enjoyment and cultural values to be gained from learning music cannot genuinely be compared to the benefits of becoming literate. Secondly, it is a fact that literacy is a guarantee of academic progress and the absorption of information, while playing music does not offer this security. For example, it would be unimaginable to transmit scientific or mathematical information to children via the medium of music. Finally, it is surely wiser to regard music as one of a wide range of secondary skills, ranking below literacy and sitting alongside sports, hobbies, foreign languages and other important but less essential activities.
Of course, those who say that highly talented children must be allowed to develop their talents are quite correct; it is equally true, though, that few children seem to possess musical ability to the extent that it should be prioritized so highly for all pupils.
In conclusion, I would not wish to underestimate the potential benefits of learning to play music for a minority of children, and it should certainly be available as an option. However, if we think of all children in a given community, literacy appears to be a far stronger pathway to progress and independence.
The question of which
skills
to prioritize for a child’s early education is
important
for all
parents and educators, and
music
can
certainly
claim to be a key possibility when deciding which abilities to teach.
However
, I feel that playing
music
is actually less
important
than basic
literacy
, and I will
explain
the reasons here.
Firstly
, it seems simplistic to say that
music
is paramount ‘for all
children
. ’
Certainly
, there are
some
children
who are
highly
talented or have great interest in
music
, and when we
think
of childhood prodigies such as Beethoven or
Yehudi
Menuhin we
see
how this talent can
be brought
out.
However
, such talents are rare, and even the enjoyment and cultural values to
be gained
from learning
music
cannot
genuinely
be compared
to the benefits of becoming literate.
Secondly
, it is a fact that
literacy
is a guarantee of academic progress and the absorption of information, while playing
music
does not offer this security.
For example
, it would be unimaginable to transmit scientific or mathematical information to
children
via the medium of
music
.
Finally
, it is
surely
wiser to regard
music
as one of a wide range of secondary
skills
, ranking below
literacy
and sitting alongside sports, hobbies, foreign languages and other
important
but
less essential activities.
Of course
, those who say that
highly
talented
children
must
be
allowed
to develop their talents are quite correct; it is
equally
true, though, that few
children
seem to possess musical ability to the extent that it should
be prioritized
so
highly
for all pupils.
In conclusion
, I would not wish to underestimate the potential benefits of learning to play
music
for a minority of
children
, and it should
certainly
be available as an option.
However
, if we
think
of all
children
in a
given
community,
literacy
appears to be a far stronger pathway to progress and independence.